Effective Backlink Prioritization for Better Search Engine Results
Table of Contents
- April 16, 2025
Sharing is Caring
Not all backlinks are created equal. In the world of SEO, understanding which backlink types deserve the most attention can be the difference between a campaign that drives meaningful results and one that wastes valuable resources. This guide will walk you through a strategic approach to backlink prioritization, helping you allocate your efforts where they’ll have the greatest impact.
Based on extensive analysis of backlink effectiveness, we’ve categorized 35 backlink types into a three-tier system and assigned recommended percentage allocations for a balanced SEO campaign. This prioritization takes into account factors like authority transfer, relevance potential, acquisition difficulty, and long-term SEO value.
The Backlink Priority Pyramid
- Top Tier (High Priority): 52% of total effort
- Mid Tier (Medium Priority): 30% of total effort
- Lower Tier (Supplementary): 18% of total effort
Top Tier Backlinks (52% of Effort)
.EDU and .GOV Backlinks (7%)
Educational and governmental links remain among the most valuable backlink types due to their inherent authority and trustworthiness. While challenging to acquire, these links can significantly boost your domain authority.
Acquisition Strategies:
- Create scholarship programs or educational resources
- Develop research papers or studies of interest to educational institutions
- Participate in government RFPs (Request for Proposals) or vendor programs
- Contribute valuable data to public research projects
Resource Page Backlinks (10%)
Resource pages are specifically designed to link to valuable content, making them ideal backlink sources. These pages exist to curate helpful information, making them relatively receptive to outreach when you have genuinely valuable content.
Acquisition Strategies:
- Create comprehensive guides, tools, or resources
- Research relevant resource pages using search operators like “keyword + resources”
- Conduct personalized outreach explaining the value your content adds
- Focus on resource pages within your specific niche
Guest Blogging (12%)
Guest blogging should receive the largest allocation of your effort, as it consistently delivers strong results when done properly. This strategy involves creating content for other websites in exchange for attribution and links.
Acquisition Strategies:
- Identify relevant blogs that accept guest contributors
- Develop unique, valuable pitches tailored to each site
- Focus on quality over quantity, prioritizing authoritative industry publications
- Create exceptional content that serves the host site’s audience
- Include contextual links where they add genuine value
Broken Backlink Building (8%)
This strategy involves finding broken links on other websites and suggesting your content as a replacement. It’s effective because you’re solving a problem for the website owner while gaining a backlink.
Acquisition Strategies:
- Use tools like Ahrefs, SEMrush, or Check My Links to find broken links
- Create content that serves as an appropriate replacement
- Craft helpful outreach emails that focus on the value to the site owner
- Track your success rates and refine your approach
Building Relationships (7%)
Some of the best backlinks come through genuine relationships with others in your industry. Allocating time to relationship building is a long-term investment that pays dividends across your SEO efforts.
Acquisition Strategies:
- Engage authentically with influencers and content creators in your niche
- Provide value before asking for links
- Participate in industry events and online communities
- Collaborate on content or projects with complementary businesses
- Focus on building genuine connections, not just link opportunities
Linkable Assets (8%)
Creating highly valuable content specifically designed to attract links (linkable assets) is a cornerstone of effective SEO. These assets continue generating links over time, making them worth the significant investment.
Acquisition Strategies:
- Conduct original research or surveys
- Create free tools or calculators
- Develop comprehensive guides or tutorials
- Design informative infographics or data visualizations
- Regularly promote your assets to relevant audiences
Mid Tier Backlinks (30% of Effort)
Industry Roundups (5%)
Contributing to expert roundups puts your brand alongside recognized industry leaders while earning valuable backlinks.
Acquisition Strategies:
- Monitor for roundup opportunities via HARO and similar platforms
- Provide concise, insightful responses that demonstrate expertise
- Create your own roundups featuring industry experts
- Deliver genuine value rather than promotional content
Case Study Backlinks (5%)
Case studies about how you’ve successfully used another company’s product or service often earn backlinks when that company features your success story.
Acquisition Strategies:
- Identify products or services your business uses effectively
- Document specific, measurable results
- Reach out to the companies with a well-crafted case study
- Include visual elements and testimonials to enhance appeal
Podcast Guesting (4%)
Appearing as a guest on industry podcasts can earn backlinks from show notes pages while expanding your audience reach.
Acquisition Strategies:
- Identify relevant podcasts in your industry
- Develop compelling topic ideas that provide value to listeners
- Craft personalized pitches highlighting your expertise
- Prepare thoroughly for appearances
- Mention specific resources that hosts can link to
Infographic Backlinks (4%)
Well-designed infographics that present valuable information in a visually appealing format can attract numerous backlinks.
Acquisition Strategies:
- Research topics that would benefit from visual explanation
- Focus on original data or unique insights
- Ensure professional design and branding
- Create embed codes to facilitate sharing
- Conduct targeted outreach to relevant websites
Link Reclamation (5%)
Identifying and fixing situations where you should be getting backlinks but aren’t provides some of the highest conversion rates in link building.
Acquisition Strategies:
- Monitor for unlinked brand mentions
- Check for broken links to your content
- Look for uncredited use of your images or data
- Craft polite outreach requesting proper attribution
- Make it easy for webmasters to implement the fix
Brand Mentions (4%)
Converting unlinked mentions of your brand into actual backlinks is relatively straightforward and offers good returns.
Acquisition Strategies:
- Set up alerts for your brand name and variations
- Identify mentions that don’t include links
- Reach out politely to request link addition
- Express gratitude regardless of the outcome
- Make the process easy by providing the exact URL
Competitor Backlink Analysis (3%)
While this is primarily a research tool, allocating time to analyzing competitor backlinks helps identify proven opportunities in your niche.
Acquisition Strategies:
- Identify your top-performing competitors
- Use SEO tools to analyze their backlink profiles
- Look for patterns and repeatable opportunities
- Create a prioritized list of target websites
- Develop a plan to acquire similar or better links
Additional Mid-Tier Strategies (2-3% each)
These backlink types still provide solid value and deserve allocation in your strategy:
- Certification and Accreditation (2%)
- Testimonial Backlinks (3%)
- Influencer Backlinks (2%)
- Partnership Backlinks (2%)
- Video Backlinks (2%)
Lower Tier Backlinks (18% of Effort)
Lower Priority but Valuable (1-1.5% each)
- Webinar Hosting (1%)
- Association Memberships (1%)
- Q&A Site Links (1.5%)
Small but Steady Returns (1% each)
- “Best of” List Submissions (1%)
- Product Review Backlinks (1%)
- Niche Community Participation (1%)
- Image Link Building (1%)
- Directory Submissions (1%)
Minimal Investment Strategies (0.5% each)
- Event Sponsorship Backlinks (0.5%)
- Presentation Sharing (0.5%)
- Web 2.0 Properties (0.5%)
- Press Release Backlinks (0.5%)
Supplementary Tactics (0.1-0.3% each)
These backlink types should receive minimal investment but can still contribute to a natural, diverse backlink profile:
- Job Board Backlinks (0.3%)
- Forum Backlinks (0.3%)
- Wiki Backlinks (0.2%)
- Blog Commenting (0.2%)
- Social Bookmarking (0.1%)
Implementing Your Prioritized Backlink Strategy
1. Audit Your Current Backlink Profile
Before making changes, analyze your existing backlink profile to identify gaps and opportunities. Use tools like Ahrefs, SEMrush, or Moz to answer:
- Which backlink types are you currently strong/weak in?
- How does your profile compare to competitors?
- Where are the biggest opportunities for improvement?
2. Allocate Resources Based on Priority
Translate the percentage allocations into actual time, budget, or staff resources. For example, if you have 20 hours per week for link building:
- Top Tier (52%): 10.4 hours
- Mid Tier (30%): 6 hours
- Lower Tier (18%): 3.6 hours
3. Create a Balanced Calendar
Develop a content and outreach calendar that reflects your priorities:
- Daily: Relationship building, monitoring for brand mentions
- Weekly: Guest blogging pitches, resource page outreach
- Monthly: Creating linkable assets, conducting competitor analysis
- Quarterly: Pursuing .EDU/.GOV opportunities, developing case studies
4. Track and Measure Results
Monitor which strategies deliver the best results for your specific situation:
- Track acquisition rates by backlink type
- Measure the impact on rankings, traffic, and conversions
- Calculate the ROI of different strategies
- Adjust your allocation based on performance data
5. Adapt to Your Specific Situation
While this prioritization framework provides a solid starting point, your optimal allocation may vary based on:
- Your industry and competition
- Your website’s current authority
- Available resources and expertise
- Business goals and timeline
Special Considerations
For New Websites
If you’re building backlinks for a new website, consider:
- Focusing even more heavily on the top 5-7 strategies initially (60-70%)
- Prioritizing relationship building and guest blogging
- Creating 1-2 exceptional linkable assets before aggressive outreach
- Building a foundation of quality content that deserves links
For Local Businesses
Local businesses should adjust their strategy to include:
- Higher emphasis on local directory submissions (3-4%)
- Greater focus on local business associations
- Prioritizing local publications for guest posting
- Building relationships with complementary local businesses
For Competitive Niches
In highly competitive industries:
- Increase allocation to original research and data (10-12%)
- Invest more in relationship building with industry influencers
- Create more sophisticated linkable assets
- Conduct more thorough competitor backlink analysis
Conclusion
A strategic, prioritized approach to backlink building ensures you invest your resources where they’ll generate the greatest return. By allocating 52% of your efforts to high-priority backlinks, 30% to medium-priority strategies, and 18% to supplementary tactics, you’ll build a natural, diverse backlink profile that drives sustainable SEO results.
Remember that backlink building is a long-term investment. Consistently applying these principles over time will help you establish authority, improve rankings, and ultimately increase qualified traffic to your website.
The most successful link builders understand that quality always trumps quantity. One high-authority, relevant backlink often provides more value than dozens of low-quality links. Focus your primary efforts on the top-tier strategies, supplement with mid-tier tactics, and round out your profile with lower-tier methods for a balanced, effective approach.
Meet The Author
John Wilson
John, the driving force behind Optisite Rocket, spent 10 fulfilling years as the owner of a contracting company, where he honed his skills and developed a deep love for the contracting industry. Seeing the dismal results from hiring many “experts” to build his website and do his SEO, he realized he needed to learn how to do this himself. This allowed him to build a thriving company in his local area. A sudden injury, however, curtailed his ability to continue hands-on work. Undeterred, John now channels his passion into educating and inspiring others. He aims to equip aspiring professionals with the necessary knowledge and tools to excel in this rewarding field.
Get measurable results from online marketing
Our Newest Articles
Frequently Asked Questions
How long before I see results from this prioritized approach?
Backlink building typically shows initial results within 2-3 months, with more significant impacts after 4-6 months of consistent effort. Top-tier strategies often take longer to implement but provide more sustainable results, while lower-tier tactics may show quicker but smaller gains.
Rather than focusing on a specific number, analyze the backlink profiles of websites currently ranking for your target keywords. This will give you a realistic benchmark for what you need to achieve in your specific situation.
Should I completely avoid the lowest-priority backlink types?
No, even the lowest-priority backlink types serve a purpose in creating a natural, diverse backlink profile. The key is appropriate resource allocation—not elimination. Just don’t expect significant ranking improvements from these tactics alone.
How often should I reassess my backlink priorities?
Conduct a thorough review of your backlink strategy quarterly, with minor adjustments monthly based on performance data. Additionally, reassess whenever you notice significant changes in your industry, competition, or search engine algorithms.
- The authority of the linking website
- The relevance of the link to your content
- Your existing backlink profile
- The competitiveness of your target keywords
- The frequency of search engine algorithm updates
Backlink building should be viewed as a long-term strategy, with consistent efforts over time yielding the best results.
What if I have limited resources and can't implement all these strategies?
With limited resources, focus almost exclusively on the top 3-5 backlink types. It’s better to excel at a few high-priority strategies than to spread yourself too thin across many. As you gain traction, gradually expand your approach.
- Links from websites with a history of spam
- Links from irrelevant websites or content
- Links with over-optimized anchor text
- Links from private blog networks
- Paid links without proper disclosure
- Links from hacked websites
If you discover harmful backlinks pointing to your site, you can use Google’s disavow tool as a last resort to tell search engines to ignore these links.
How does this prioritization work with other SEO efforts?
This backlink prioritization should be part of a holistic SEO strategy that includes technical SEO, on-page optimization, and content creation. In fact, many top-tier backlink strategies depend on having excellent content to link to, creating natural synergies with your content marketing efforts.
However, it’s good practice to periodically audit your backlink profile and consider disavowing links that:
- Come from spammy or malicious websites
- Appear manipulative or unnatural
- Have been created through practices that violate search engine guidelines
- Could potentially trigger penalties
Focus on building new, high-quality links while monitoring your existing backlink profile for any issues that need addressing.
